The high cost of the Pa. Turnpike is taking a toll on all of us. Lawmakers should approve this plan for relief | Opinion

August 7, 2019 6:30 am

To the surprise of no one and the disgust of everyone, the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission recently announced that it will raise tolls by 6 percent, effective Jan. 5, 2020.

After raising tolls only five times during the first 64 years of the Pennsylvania Turnpike’s existence, tolls will now be raised for a 12th straight year. As late as 2006, it cost $14.70 to travel the entire 356 miles of the highway.

Next year such a trip is estimated to cost $61.78.

However, the good news is there’s a plan being proposed by two Bucks County Democratic legislators which could help offset the cost of the tolls. But the bad news is that the Republicans, who control both the state House and Senate, have shown absolutely no interest in the legislation.

Sen. Steve Santarsiero and Rep. Perry Warren are sponsoring companion Senate and House bills offering an annual state income tax credit of 50 percent of tolls paid, with a $500 cap.  Under the legislation, individuals, corporations and small businesses with tax liability would be eligible. In order to qualify, all tax credit filers would be required to submit valid E-ZPass documentation.

They recently held a press conference to outline their plans.

Commuters, families and businesses across southeastern Pennsylvania, who regularly pay tolls to maintain our roads and bridges, deserve the tax relief outlined in [his bill] SB451,” Santarsiero said, according a story in the Bucks County Courier Times.

This legislation will reduce the cost of commuting, reduce business costs, and will spur economic development,” Warren told the newspaper. “Through a commuter tax credit, we are looking to benefit our community and build our economy.”

In addition to providing some much needed help for turnpike drivers, the measure would also produce an additional 2.5 percent annual revenue hike for the financially troubled Turnpike.

Why Pennsylvania transportation funding could be in deep trouble

As much as people might want to blame turnpike officials for the endless increases, they didn’t create this problem.

The problem began in 2007, when the Legislature needed to raise transportation revenues. Instead of raising the gas tax, which always sets off political firestorms, lawmakers settled on the idea of raising $450 million annually by tolling Interstate 80, and placing higher tolls on the turnpike.

However, the tolling of I-80 was rejected by the federal government. The state Legislature could have devised another means to raise the necessary revenue but decided to do the easy thing and let turnpike motorists foot the entire $450 million payment through higher tolls.

To make the $450 million payment, the Turnpike Commission has been forced to borrow money year after year. Last year, the commission had to turn to Wall Street for relief, taking on $11.8 in debt, according to the Tribune-Review.

Pennsylvania Auditor General Eugene DePasquale has been issuing warnings about the turnpike’s troubled finances for years.

Last March, he told the Tribune-Review that, absent legislative action, the Turnpike is “on the path to bankruptcy.” He said the high tolls are forcing drivers to take alternate routes thereby depriving the turnpike of much needed revenues.

DePasquale added that even those who don’t use the turnpike are paying the price in terms of the dangers from additional traffic diverted to roads not built to carry it and higher costs for goods that must travel on the turnpike.

“Today, truckers pay $183.50 one-way for a trip across the state,” DePasquale told the Tribune-Revoew. “In less than 20 years, they will be paying over $400 one way.” Higher tolls is simply not the solution to the turnpike’s financial problems, he added.

Meanwhile, Republicans who control the General Assembly have done nothing to even try and find a solution to the problem.

Santarsiero and Warren have introduced similar bills in past years and they’ve gone nowhere. Republican House and Senate committee chairs have not allowed them to even come up for a vote. They also have not permitted any hearings or discussions about the bills.

The Pa. Turnpike toll debacle is our next financial crisis. This is how to fix it | Opinion

Not, that Republicans seem to have any particular problems with the bills. In fact, they’ve just ignored the measures. It seems as if their main opposition to the bills comes more from the fact that Santarsiero and Warren are Democrats more than anything else.

If they were Republicans, there’s a good chance the legislation would have become law by now.

Perhaps the only way to break the logjam would be if enough people contacted their lawmakers, especially Republicans, and demanded that action be taken. Unless Republicans can come up a better plan, they should approve the turnpike toll rebate.

Opinion contributor Mark O’Keefe, of Mechanicsburg, Pa., is the former Editorial Page Editor of the Uniontown Herald-Standard. His work appears regularly on the Capital-Star’s Commentary Page. 

Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.

Mark O'Keefe
Mark O'Keefe

Opinion contributor Mark O'Keefe, of Mechanicsburg, Pa.,  is the former editorial page editor of the Herald-Standard of Uniontown. His work appears biweekly on the Capital-Star's Commentary Page.