Social platforms get graded on efforts to fight hate. Here’s how they ranked. | Tuesday Coffee
None of the nine social platforms included in the report earned an A.
(c) Jirapong – Stock.Adobe.com
Good Tuesday Morning, Fellow Seekers.
What social media platforms do you use? How do they address cyberhate and antisemitism?
If your answer to the second question is “I don’t know,” keep reading.
On Monday, the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), a nationwide anti-hate organization, released its 2021 Online Antisemitism Report Card.
While none of the nine social platforms included in the report earned an A, Twitter and YouTube came the closest with a B-.
The anti-hate organization said Twitter and YouTube earned the highest grades for their “robust” hate policies and efforts to address antisemitism.
“Both products incorporated recommendations from ADL and other organizations by adding prompts that warn users before they post potentially violative comments and allow users who create video content on the platform to self-identify to help the platform better understand how different marginalized groups are targeted,” ADL noted in its report.
The report acknowledged some recent changes to Twitter’s policies that put it at the top of the scorecard.
“It has broad anti-hate policies in place and has introduced effective product-level efforts to address antisemitism, including the use of prompts and its shift last summer to scan external links for hateful content that violate its policies,” the report reads.
Platforms Reddit and Twitch earned a C, tying for third place.
“Twitch did significantly better than Reddit when it came to taking action on antisemitic content by responding to reported content within a 72-hour window and actioning the majority of the antisemitic content that ADL flagged. Nevertheless, its lack of a formal trusted flagger program and less than ideal data accessibility for researchers earned it the same grade as Reddit,” the report explained.
Coming in with a C- were TikTok, Facebook/Instagram and Discord.
ADL said the so-so grade was issued to these four platforms because they failed to provide any details about how enforcement decisions were reached when responding to reported content.
Additionally, ADL reported that all four failed to take action against content reported by the ADL through user flagging.
In the bottom spot was Roblox, an online game platform, which received the worst score of the nine platforms studied.
ADL noted that Roblox did not respond to or take action against reported content.
So, why does all this matter?
2020 saw a 4 percent decrease in antisemitic incidents from 2019, according to ADL data. Despite this decrease, 2020 was still the third-highest year on record for antisemitic incidents since the ADL began recording them in 1979.
According to the survey, 36 percent of Jewish respondents said they experienced some form of online harassment. Thirty-one percent of Jewish respondents who were exposed to online hate reported that they felt targeted because of their religion.
From our partners at The Philadelphia Tribune: Report offers ways to address inequities among Philly’s minority-owned small businesses
On our Commentary Page this morning, Bruce Ledewitz writes: What a Novel Can Teach Us about Religion in America and columnist Ray E. Landis looks at the costs of the Wolf administration’s proposed long-term care home regulations.
Marley Parish reports: Gov. Wolf asks lawmakers to make an early return to Harrisburg, extend opioid declaration
In this week’s Numbers Racket: What Pa. county has the most miles of hiking trails?
The latest from the Pa. House: Special election for former Rep. Margo Davidson’s seat to be held Nov. 2
Philly region seeing a ‘substantial’ spread of COVID-19, expanding the area where indoor masks are recommended, The Philadelphia Inquirer reports.
The York Dispatch reports: Mysterious ‘election integrity committee’ puts pressure on York County officials
A Pennsylvania judge has halted work on a connection bridge at Lehigh Valley International Airport over contract rules. The Morning Call has the story.
PA Lottery reports a record $1.3 billion in profits. These were the most popular games, according to the Lebanon Daily News.
What Goes On
The House Appropriation and Education Committees will hold a public hearing at 10 a.m. on the PASSHE implementation plan.
The House Legislative Reapportionment Commission will hold a public hearing on legislative reapportionment Tuesday at 2 p.m.
The House Legislative Reapportionment Commission will meet again Tuesday at 6 p.m. for citizen feedback on legislative reapportionment.
No public appearances at this time.
A blast from the past, here’s the Beastie Boys 1998 jam “Intergalactic.”
What We’re Reading
The Penn Capital-Star Readers book club on Goodreads is currently reading “Women and Other Monsters” by Jess Zimmerman. To join in on our next read or recommend a book, visit our Goodreads page.
And now you’re up to date.
Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.