In central Pa., a new wall?: How a Trump rule could come between immigrants and their doctors | Friday Morning Coffee

(Photo via pxHere.com)

Good Friday Morning, Fellow Seekers.

File this one under: Watch what the Trump administration does — not what it says.

As our friends at Stateline.org report, the White House wants to relax an Obama-era rule “requiring that medical providers let patients know about their right to language interpretation services — and for people with disabilities, communication assistance such as qualified sign language interpreters or written information in alternative formats for the visually impaired. The administration insists that the current requirements are onerous and costly for providers.”

To underline the real-world implications of this change, consider a scenario that unfolded in a physician’s office about hour away from the state Capitol in Harrisburg.

Once again, from our friends at Stateline:

Ed Zuroweste, a family practitioner in south central Pennsylvania, got a call a couple of years ago from a nearby hospital in Chambersburg. A restaurant worker, newly arrived from Guatemala, had staggered into the emergency room a few days before with severe shortness of breath and coughing up blood.

Using as a translator the man’s co-worker, a Mexican national with limited English himself, the staff took a medical history. They ruled out tuberculosis because the Guatemalan said he had not had contact with anyone with the infection. They treated him for pneumonia and released him a couple of days later.

Then the results came back from the specimen they had cultured. The Guatemalan had tuberculosis after all.Zuroweste received the call because he is a tuberculosis expert who consults with the state health department on the infectious disease. Fluent in Spanish, Zuroweste ended up contacting the Guatemalan and successfully treating him.

The man told Zuroweste that back home he had been exposed to a friend and a brother who each had the disease. He hadn’t wanted to admit that in front of his co-worker, whom he barely knew, because of the stigma associated with tuberculosis. “I hope I don’t die of TB,” he told Zuroweste. He didn’t.

To the doctor, the incident points to the need for professional medical translation services for patients with limited English proficiency, which is guaranteed in federal law but often ignored, immigrant advocates say. Without translation services, Zuroweste said, there are likely to be misunderstandings that result in medical mishaps, mistreatment and avoidable health care costs

President Donald Trump (Capital-Star file)

And now, that Trump rule could make things even worse, public health experts warned Stateline, with far-reaching implications. That’s because more than 27 million U.S. residents speak English less than “very well” or not at all, Stateline reported, citing Census data.

More from Stateline:

Under the proposed rule, patients would still have a right to language services, they simply might not know they do or how to go about getting those services.

Under the current rules, health care providers must have in-house plans on how they’ll provide language services, and they must post in their offices that patients have a right to language services and steps they can take to get them.

Providers also must include in “significant communications” with patients taglines in 15 languages that explain that patients have a right to language services and how to go about receiving them. Those notifications apply to assistance for non-English speakers and to those with impaired hearing or vision.

The rules also specify that non-English speakers have a right to qualified, professional interpreters, a signal that family members, and particularly minor children, are not sufficient to serve as translators.

“I think it’s a very dangerous step,” Harvard Medical School associate professor Alexander Green told Stateline. “It’s starting a process of eroding people’s rights to high-quality health services at a time when we are on a trajectory to remove disparities in health care. This is a motion to turn back the clock and cause more disparities in health care.”

Mexico–United States barrier at the border of Tijuana, Mexico and San Diego, USA. The crosses represent migrants who died in the crossing attempt. Some identified, some not. Surveillance tower in the background.
WikiMedia Commons Image by Tomascastelazo.

While the administration says the move would save money, the public health cost, according to Stateline, is still dear:

Studies have shown that inadequate language services can result in consequential medical mistakes, including death. Patients may be unable to describe their symptoms for doctors or complete medical histories. They may not understand medication regimens or discharge instructions.

A 2010 study by the University of California Berkeley School of Public Health, published by the National Health Law Program, of a medical malpractice carrier operating in four states found that 2.5% of the carrier’s claims, resulting in nearly $2.3 million in damages or settlements, could be attributed to a provider’s failure to provide adequate interpretive services.

Even without the changes sought by the Trump administration, compliance with the current language requirements is lagging, advocates say. “Right now, with the regs we have, we hear these stories of people with limited English proficiency not getting adequate access to interpretive services,” said Kathy Ko Chin, CEO of the Asian & Pacific Islander American Health Forum, an immigrant health advocacy organization based in Oakland, California.

People who do not speak English very well come back from their medical providers, she said, “and really don’t know what happened to them. They don’t know what their medication regimen is, what it’s for, and how to use it.”

Walls, we cannot help but conclude, come in many different shapes and sizes.

WikiMedia Commons

Our Stuff.
More states are letting candidates use campaign funds to cover childcare expenses. Where does Pa. fall? Sarah Anne Hughes has your answer.

Stephen Caruso has all you need to know about the new recommendations from the Wolf administration’s Redistricting Reform Commission.

State lawmakers from northeastern Pennsylvania are lining up against a Wolf administration plan to shut down a state prison in their backyardElizabeth Hardison reports.

In a sternly worded letter to the EPA, Maryland Gov. Larry Hogan slammed Pennsylvania’s for failing to live up to its obligations to help keep the Chesapeake Bay clean. The administration’s response is, well, decidedly crabby.

On our Commentary Page, new Opinion contributor Lloyd E. Sheaffer has one demand for the 2020 Dems: Spare him the bumper stickers and baseball caps. Tell him what you’re going to do. And sexual abuse among gay and bisexual men brings with it unique stigma and harm, two trauma psychiatrists contend.

Elsewhere.
Here’s the Inquirer on the controversy over Philadelphia’s new Register of Wills Tracey Gordon — who hasn’t even taken office yet.
Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto is ‘touting’ the city’s ‘varied’ approach to handling stabbings downtown, the Post-Gazette reports.
PHEAA will close a loan servicing office in the Philadelphia suburbs, PennLive reports.
Lehigh Valley companies won’t be leaving China, saying President Donald Trump can’t order them to do that, the Morning Call reports.

Here’s your #Pennsylvania Instagram of the Day:

Here’s WHYY-FM on the factors complicating the clean-up at the PES refinery in Philly, which was ravaged by fire earlier this summer.
The PA Post has its take on the Redistricting Reform Commission’s new report, focusing on state residents’ frustration with the lack of transparency surrounding the decennial remapping.
Republican National Committee Chairwoman Ronna McDaniel was in Philly this week, where she bragged about the Trump economy, PoliticsPA reports.
Ohio elections officials will let the ballots of some purged voters count during upcoming elections, Talking Points Memo reports.

WolfWatch.
Gov. Tom Wolf 
has no public schedule today.

What Goes On (Nakedly Political Edition).
State Rep. Aaron Bernstine 
holds an 8 a.m. golf outing at Del Mar Golf Club in scenic Wampum, Pa. Admission runs $50 to $400.

You Say It’s Your Birthday Dept. 
Have a birthday that you’d like mentioned in this space? Hit us up at [email protected].

Heavy Rotation.
Oasis’ 
legendary debut LP ‘Definitely Maybe,’ incomprehensibly turned 25 years old this week. It’s hard to understate what a game-changer this record was in its day. Here’s one of our favorite tracks: “Up in the Sky.”

Friday’s Gratuitous Baseball Link.
These are the MLB clubs with the bumpiest road to October. And, yes, we’re looking at you, Philadelphia.

And now you’re up to date.

An award-winning political journalist with more than 25 years' experience in the news business, John L. Micek is The Pennsylvania Capital-Star's Editor-in-Chief. Before joining The Capital-Star, Micek spent six years as Opinion Editor at PennLive/The Patriot-News in Harrisburg, Pa., where he helped shape and lead a multiple-award-winning Opinion section for one of Pennsylvania's most-visited news websites. Prior to that, he spent 13 years covering Pennsylvania government and politics for The Morning Call of Allentown, Pa. His career has also included stints covering Congress, Chicago City Hall and more municipal meetings than he could ever count, Micek contributes regular analysis and commentary to a host of broadcast outlets, including CTV-News in Canada and talkRadio in London, U.K., as well as "Face the State" on CBS-21 in Harrisburg, Pa.; "Pennsylvania Newsmakers" on WGAL-8 in Lancaster, Pa., and the Pennsylvania Cable Network. His weekly column on American politics is syndicated nationwide to more than 800 newspapers by Cagle Syndicate.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here