This Philly lawmaker wants Pennsylvania to offer reparations to its black residents

State Rep. Chris Rabb, D-Philadelphia, speaks at a Capitol news conference on House and Senate proposals to abolish the death penalty in Pennsylvania (Capital-Star photo by John L. Micek)

One Pennsylvania lawmaker is making his own case for reparations  — not just for slavery, but for 400 years of institutional racism. 

Rep. Chris Rabb, D-Philadelphia, released a memo last week asking for his colleagues’ support for a bill providing tax credits or other benefits to African Americans as well as “targeted geographic communities.”

Citing Pennsylvania’s own state Constitution, the memo says that “it is clear that the constitutional rights of an entire people have been limited, if not wholly denied based on the policies and inaction of their own state government for centuries.”

Reparations to African Americans for both 250 years of enslavement and then decades of racism from public institutions has been advocated on a national scale by public intellectuals like Ta-Nehisi Coates

Congress saw its first reparations bill in 1989, and held its first hearing in a decade on the topic earlier this year. The Democratic presidential candidates have even begun to actively discuss plans to compensate descendents of enslaved people.

Rabb believes his proposal is the first offered on a state level. He also thinks it’s the proper jurisdiction.

“Slavery was not a federal law, it was a state law,” Rabb told the Capital-Star. “What state you were born in decided whether you were fully human or property.”

Slavery existed in Pennsylvania as early as 1639, and William Penn himself owned African slaves, preferring them to white indentured servants because “for then a man has them while they live.” Paradoxically, the Keystone State was founded by Quakers, like Penn, who would become early advocates against the institution.

At slavery’s peak in Pennsylvania, enslaved people made up 5 percent of the colony’s population — about 6,000 out of 120,000 people in 1750, according to the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission.

In 1780, Pennsylvania passed the first law abolishing slavery in the United States, but as the PHMC notes, it was ultimately among the most conservative.. 

It only freed a Pennsylvania-born black person when they turned 28 years old. The Legislature tried, unsuccessfully, to repeal its own abolition in 1781.

But Rabb specifically said he doesn’t see his proposal as one to target just the horrors of slavery. 

He cited recent examples of discrimination, such as redlining — or the systemic denial of federal mortages to African Americans by lenders — as well as histroic underinvestment in black communities, as necessitating his proposal.

Reporting from the investigative nonprofit Reveal found that despite a 50-year-old ban on housing discrimination, banks still routinely deny African Americans mortages in cities such as Philadelphia.

Rabb’s bill would specifically have Pennsylvania apologize for its complicity in white supremacy, and acknowledge that current racial inequities “are borne of racist public policy enacted into state and federal laws.”

It would also create a commission to financially quantify the damage to the black community from racism over centuries.

Rabb said his plan would specifically not allow for cash payments. He instead expects it to mostly rely on tax credits addressing public safety, education, or health among other topics.

As for the potential cost, Rabb did not cite a number but said his plan should attract support among fiscal conservatives. He argued a large jolt of investment now to poorer African-American communities could drive down the future spending “that make[s] our budget so big.”

Also, at a time when the state already OKs millions in tax carveouts for businesses, Rabb feels his proposal is the least he can do.

“If we can rationalize a half a billion* [dollars] in tax credits to our more privileged residents of the commonwealth, then we can absolutely entertain a program that provides financial redress for one of the most aggrieved communities in our country,” he said.

The bill, introduced to coincide with the 400th anniversary of a slave ship’s arrival in the Virginia colony, already has three co-sponsors, according to Rabb, including Legislative Black Caucus Chair Rep. Stephen Kinsey, D-Philadelphia, and Rep. Joe Webster, D-Montgomery.

This piece was updated to correct a quote from Rep. Chris Rabb.

7 COMMENTS

  1. I understand that slavery was a dark time in the history of the United States .
    The issue before us is why should taxpayers of today pay for something they had no control over or cause? I was not part of slavery nor my parents, grandparents or even great grandparents. Who should be given appropriations? I am not sure there is anyone alive that was a slave during that time. For those that would cry racism this is not about racism, If you wish to debate racism that is a whole nother issue.

  2. Would this be a “given” based solely on skin color, or would a recipient have to provide evidence to qualify? Also, does this proposal include other races of people who have suffered? If so, a great many will see compensation coming their way. I wish we could go back to when Civil rights we’re on the mend, rather than the “stirring of the pot” mentality rearing it’s destructive head yet again. America bless God and love your neighbor- whatever his skin color is.

  3. Pennsylvania passed its Gradual Abolition of Slavery in 1780 and then my direct ancestor, a Captain in Pennsylvania’s 62nd regiment gave his life at the Battle of Gaine’s Mills for abolition and union … Where is my handout?

  4. This is the most ridiculous thing I’ve heard. This guy needs to be fired!!! Where’s reperations for the Irish, the Jews, Chinese.. all of whom endured the same treatment if not worse.. it’s officially getting out of hand in this country.. move the f on already, go to work, support your kids and pay your own bills. As a tax payer I’m tired of paying for welfare recipients who abuse the system… for guess who??? Why doesn’t this State Rep look into the career recipients of welfare. Another Dem looking out for himself for votes.

  5. I am appalled that anyone today wants this. There hasn’t been a slave since 1863 and the majority of the people in Pennsylvania came here in the great migration of the 1880s and 1890s. They never owned a slave in their life. In fact, they were treated almost as a slave economically. The Irish, Polish, Jewish, Italians came here with barely anything and worked for pennies until their children moved up the social ladder with education and grit. In my case, my father as a coal miner who started out as a boy working in the mines as a slate picker and my brother and I graduated from college thru their insistence on us getting a great education. I owe nothing these people who want to “milk” the system with their tale of woe. Not one dime. Stop bitching about your past and work on your future.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here