The GOP’s anti-abortion crusade is not pro-family at all | Wednesday Morning Coffee
There’s always been a fatal flaw in the arguments of anti-abortion forces: Their indifference to children after they’re born
More than a thousand anti-abortion demonstrators gathered on the Capitol steps for the first Pennsylvania March for Life (Capital-Star photo by Marley Parish).
Good Wednesday Morning, Fellow Seekers.
In the hours after the bombshell leak of U.S. Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito’s draft opinion toppling Roe v. Wade, I awaited the torrent of Republican-authored press releases vowing to provide every resource the federal government could muster to support the millions of new families they were going to usher into existence.
Of course, that didn’t happen.
Instead, I was treated to irony-free press releases from anti-abortion rights forces taking a victory lap now that their decades-long goal of stripping bodily autonomy from half the nation’s population was finally within reach.
“In Congress, I have always fought for the dignity of human life. Nothing is more important than life,” U.S. Rep. Fred Keller, R-12th District, said in a statement his office sent out on Tuesday afternoon. “After nearly 50 years since Roe v. Wade was wrongly decided, I am thrilled that we are closer than ever to delivering historic pro-life protections for the unborn.”
After birth, however? That’s a different story. The press release page of Keller’s congressional website is long on criticisms of the Biden administration, but markedly short of plans that support pregnant people or provide resources to families after their children are born.
And it would be one thing if Keller if was an outlier, but he’s not.
The fatal flaw of the GOP’s anti-abortion arguments always has been its profound indifference to the fate of the fetuses that they’re so intent on forcing pregnant people to carry to term.
It’s always been about one thing: Control. Worse, it’s an argument that’s been made by people who have taken a faith capable of depthless love and life-changing liberation, and weaponized it to marginalize the other.
Because if the inverse were true, we’d have ironclad family leave and paid sick leave laws. We’d have universal preschool and affordable childcare. We’d have an array of pre- and post-natal services for pregnant people. And, critically, we’d have done something about the nation’s shockingly high maternal mortality rate — particularly among Black women.
But we do not — and we have not.
In fact, every time I’ve had occasion to write about Republican-backed efforts to restrict abortion rights, it’s been painfully clear that only the tiniest handful of anti-choice lawmakers also have sponsored bills to support and protect pregnant people and children.
I also was treated to solemn condemnations of the person (or people) who had leaked Alito’s draft opinion — which may or may not be the final product the high court makes public when it issues its final opinion, likely in late June.
“Leaking a premature Supreme Court opinion—regardless of subject matter—undermines the Court as an institution and erodes America’s trust in this pillar of our constitutional structure,” U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., said in a statement his office issued on Tuesday.
Keller offered a similar sentiment in his own statement, saying the “breach of confidentiality represents the undermining of the Court’s ability to deliberate impartially on our nation’s most pressing issues.”
I’ll pause here to note that Keller was not so concerned about the sanctity of our institutions when he said he initially planned to object to the certification of Pennsylvania’s presidential electors, and joined a specious lawsuit that would have tossed his home state’s votes in 2020. And it was only after a violent horde sacked the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2020 that Keller recognized the legitimacy of President Joe Biden’s win.
Toomey, who has the nominal fig leaf of being one of the few Republicans who voted to impeach former President Donald Trump for his role in fomenting the insurrection, nonetheless supported every single high court nominee the constitution-battering White House sent his way. Thus, any concerns about compromising the institution went out the window the moment he cast his votes in the affirmative.
So, in the absence of any congressional vote making abortion access the law of the land, or executive action on the same by Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf on his way out the door, abortion-rights supporters should brace themselves for fresh GOP assaults in the Keystone State.
And if it didn’t already, that should further drive home the stakes of this year’s already hugely consequential campaign to replace the term-limited Wolf, who has stood as a one-man veto machine for the last eight years. At least one Republican aspirant is already rubbing his hands together with glee.
But it won’t end there.
Because, as Esquire’s Charles P. Pierce writes, if the high court can lay waste to one constitutionally protected privacy right, it can come after another. And that means same-sex marriage is at risk. It means that access to contraception is at risk. And it means that interracial marriage is at risk.
Keep in mind, the likely high court ruling will come even though a majority of Americans say they believe the high court should uphold Roe, validating years of steady campaigning by a noisy, but exceptionally well-organized, minority who do not speak for the rest of us.
If Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis can try to ‘Don’t Say Gay‘ his way to the 2024 GOP ticket, it’s not a question of whether, but when, Republicans here will move to further marginalize our already vulnerable friends, neighbors, and work colleagues. Indeed, as the past few months have shown us it’s already happening.
The fight’s not over. Not by a long shot.
Marley Parish explains how the battle over abortion rights will shape the 2022 race for governor.
From me: Gov. Tom Wolf sounded a defiant note on abortion rights after news of the opinion became public.
President Joe Biden said Tuesday that his administration “will be ready when any ruling is issued” on abortion rights, Capital-Star Washington Reporter Ariana Figueroa reports.
A $10 million, state-run loan forgiveness program aims to address ongoing staffing shortages and the high rate of turnover among substance use disorder practitioners, Cassie Miller reports.
On our Commentary Page this morning: The CEOs of Pennsylvania’s regional Planned Parenthood offices call on Gov. Tom Wolf to take a series of executive actions to protect access to abortion. With another school year coming to a close, veteran advocate Lawrence Feinberg high-fives your neighbors who serve on their local school boards. And a Lehigh County prosecutor’s threat to charge anyone who drops off multiple ballots on primary day could end up disenfranchising disabled voters who are allowed just such assistance, Peri Jude Radecic, of Disability Rights Pennsylvania, writes this morning.
The Inquirer looks at the Christian nationalism fueling state Sen. Doug Mastriano’s, R-Franklin, bid for governor.
The Post-Gazette homes in on a proposed amendment to the Pennsylvania Constitution declaring there is no right to abortion that’s now before the Legislature.
If Roe v. Wade falls, U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., who opposes abortion becomes a “linchpin” in the fight over abortion rights, BillyPenn reports.
Pennsylvanians have a year to get a federal REAL ID, WESA-FM reports.
GoErie talks to local residents and advocates about the leaked U.S. Supreme Court opinion on abortion.
More states are erecting ‘shields’ against rogue abortion prosecutions, Stateline.org reports.
Congressional Democrats see a midterm boost from the leak, which has motivated activists and voters alike, Roll Call reports.
PennLive looks at efforts to stave off the ‘staggering’ death rate among race horses (subscriber-only).
LancasterOnline runs down what’s known about the controversy over an after-school event, put on by a high school gay alliance, that featured professional drag performers.
In the Lehigh Valley, state lawmakers took testimony on Tuesday about the nuisance posed by dirt bikes and other illegal street vehicles, the Morning Call reports.
Former President Donald Trump has endorsed GOP 8th Congressional District hopeful Jim Bognet, the Citizens’ Voice reports.
PoliticsPA puts its own spotlight on the race for the northeastern Pennsylvania congressional seat.
Here’s your #Pittsburgh Instagram of the Day:
View this post on Instagram
What Goes On
1 p.m., 418 Main Capitol: House Democratic Policy Committee
Gov. Tom Wolf holds an 11 a.m. news conference in Philadelphia this morning to talk about the leaked SCOTUS opinion, and his efforts to protect abortion access for the remainder of his term.
You Say It’s Your Birthday Dept.
Best wishes go out this morning to John Cole, of the Pennsylvania Cable Network, who celebrates today. Congratulations and enjoy the day, sir.
We’ll keep the Elephant 6 vibe rolling this morning. Here’s one of my favorites from The Olivia Tremor Control. It’s “A Peculiar Noise Called ‘Train Director.'”
Wednesday’s Gratuitous Hockey Link
The Pittsburgh Penguins topped the New York Rangers 4-3 on Tuesday night in an epic bout of bonus hockey that went to a triple overtime.
And now you’re up to date.
Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.
John L. Micek