Electric vehicle drivers in Pa. would pay $250/year fee under advancing state House bill

    The Pennsylvania Turnpike (Douglas Muth/Flickr)

    The state House has advanced legislation requiring electric vehicle drivers to pony up for the wear and tear they inflict on Pennsylvania’s roads and highways.

    The majority-Republican chamber voted 94-90 to approve an amendment hitting drivers of hybrids or fully electric vehicles with a $250 annual fee.

    Originally, the bill, sponsored by Rep. Mike Caroll, D-Luzerne, proposed a $150 annual fee on those drivers. But the chamber’s Republicans instead inserted language to increase that fee by $100.

    The fee would be paid when vehicle owners update their registration with the state.

    “We all use our roads and bridges. We all should all pay to keep them safe,” House Transportation Committee Chairman Tim Hennessey, R-Chester, said during a floor debate.

    Republicans also said drivers of fully gas-powered vehicles pay on average $272 a year through the gas tax.

    Democrats resisted the move, saying it doesn’t take the reality of electric vehicle use into account.

    Rep. Chris Rabb, D-Philadelphia, who drives an electric car, said that the lack of fast charging infrastructure in Pennsylvania limits his range to take a long road trip. 

    “I cannot go drive from Philly to Pittsburgh in my electric vehicle unless I want to find a charging system off the [Pennsylvania] Turnpike,” Rabb said.

    Because Rabb is not free to travel “hither and yon” across the state like his internal combustion engine driven colleagues, he felt the smaller fee was fair.

    Under the law, commercial electric vehicle drivers would also be charged $250 a year. Drivers of electric motorcycles would be required to pay a $50 fee each year.

    Pennsylvania pays for most of its highway and road improvements with its gas tax, the highest in the nation. Owners of plug-in electric vehicles are currently supposed to submit monthly statements of their electricity use to the state Department of Revenue, and remit the alternative fuel tax.

    “However, most electric vehicle owners don’t do this because the process for remitting the alternative fuel tax is cumbersome, or they are unaware that they have to,” a memo from Carroll reads.

    The House needs to vote on the bill a final time before sending it to the Senate. If passed by the upper chamber, the legislation would head to Gov. Tom Wolf’s desk.

    3 COMMENTS

    1. All vehicles should pay a user fee for the roads, but this bill raises current electric vehicle fees by over 300% making them more taxed than gas powered vehicles that get a 40 miles per gallon. Until Pennsylvania moves to a VMT – vehicle miles traveled – means for user fees, it is only fair to keep the gas tax rate linked to presumed gallons consumed. For an electric car travelling the average of 12,500 miles a year getting 100 mpg equivalent, that tax should be around $75, which the alternative gas tax runs.
      As far as users not paying the fees because it is cumbersome or don’t know, that’ on PennDOT to reach out to all electric vehicle owners and find a way to collect that fee during registration renewal. Mileage is relatively easy to report and track.
      Finally, the Commonwealth is giving out rebates for electric vehicle purchases. This fee would wipe that out in a 6 years of ownership. I thought we were trying to get people to buy electric cars. This will only discourage them.

    2. What else do you expect from the GOP, the party of dirty air, dirty water and carbon! My EV is 100% solar powered, you going to tax the sun next? This tax is nothing but another way to preserve your precious fossil fuel lobbies because EVs are a threat to their monopoly on fuel, meanwhile the climate is on fire! You’re better off putting a tax on the carbon the gas vehicles create!!!!

    3. You got away with years of not paying a tax, so it is time to pony up. Obama enacted the law that led to the rain tax affecting PA, so that is YOUR party taxing people to death. BTW, electric cars are even dirtier than normal cars when you take into account the full process of making, using, and disposing of them. OOPS!

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here
    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.